Warning: This article contains spoilers for the season 10 finale of The Masked Singer.

After Ken Jeong was so sure Gazelle was his friend Constance Wu all season long — going so far as to save her with the Ding Dong Keep It On bell in the Group A finals — the Masked Singer season 10 finale Wednesday night finally revealed her identity.

Despite giving it her all in a very emotional performance of Snow Patrol's "Chasing Cars," Gazelle was eliminated after Sea Queen (a.k.a. Macy Gray), and ultimately finished the season as the second runner-up.

When it came time for the panel's final guesses, Jeong of course stuck to his season-long guess of his Fresh Off the Boat and Crazy Rich Asians costar, saying, "I’ve been moved by her all season, sometimes you just gotta go with the voice and your gut... I think Gazelle is my good friend Constance Wu." Robin Thicke and Jenny McCarthy-Wahlberg, meanwhile, both guessed Ashley Tisdale, and Nicole Scherzinger opted for Gina Rodriguez.

Michael Becker / FOX

When the singer took off her mask, though, the panel was collectively stunned: No one guessed her true identity at any point during the season. Gazelle was ultimately revealed to be Pretty Little Liars actress Janel Parrish.

And though it wasn't exactly the reunion Jeong might have been hoping for, the reveal was still an emotional one for both. "Singing is my first love, it’s the first thing I ever did when I was a kid, and somewhere along my journey singing became my biggest fear and biggest insecurity. As I became known for acting it almost felt like to say I was a singer was a lie," Parrish told the panel. "But to come out here as this gorgeous Gazelle and no one knows who I am, I just got to tap into my voice and now I feel like a singer and it’s because of you guys."

She even had a hilarious apology for Jeong: "Ken, I’m sorry that I’m not Constance, but I love you and thank you for being my champion."

There were no hard feelings. Through his laughter, Jeong told Parrish he'd do it all over again if given the chance. "Honestly, I don’t regret it at all because literally you have one of the best voices I’ve ever heard on the show," he said, adding, "We’re in awe. I mean that from the bottom of my heart.”

Kevin Mazur/Getty

Stay tuned for more of EW's live Masked Singer season 10 finale coverage to see who ultimately takes home the Golden Mask Trophy.

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly's free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.

Related content: