The Drew Barrymore Show pitches celeb
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT Barrymore's cohost, Ross Mathews, also suggested Sharon Stone and Diane Keaton for their starry version of the dating competition.

Hey, ABC! The cast of The Drew Barrymore Show has some ideas for how to make the upcoming Golden Bachelorette spinoff extra rosy.

On Friday, Drew Barrymore and her cohost, Ross Mathews, were joined by Entertainment Tonight correspondent Rachel Smith to discuss a series of recent pop culture headlines, including the announcement that the first-ever Golden Bachelorette will set out on her own journey to find love this fall.

“Have they picked anyone yet?” Barrymore asked the table, to which Smith responded, “No, they haven’t picked the lucky lady yet, but, Drew and Ross, if you could submit someone, who would that [be]?”

Getty

Mathews instantly had a few famous faces in mind. “I have thoughts,” he said. “What if they did, like, a celebrity version?”

As for whom he'd like to see handing out the roses? "Well, Meryl Streep is single!” Mathews exclaimed. "Diane Keaton, Sharon Stone… there are so many hot women of that age that would be so... I would love that.”

“Oh, I’m so into that,” Smith responded, adding, “Meryl, is your calendar available?”

Barrymore, whose mouth had dropped open in surprise at the idea, happily turned toward her desk and declared, “Start that rumor right here is all I can say!”

Mathews wanting Streep to become the Golden Bachelorette comes after the actress announced last year that she and her husband, Don Gummer, have been quietly separated for over six years. As for Stone? Well, she was married twice throughout her life: first to Michael Greenburg, from 1984 until 1990, and then to Phil Bronstein, from 1998 until 2004.

Keaton, however, may be a bit harder to convince. She told AARP last year that her ever dating again is "highly unlikely," saying, "I don’t remember anyone calling me, going, ‘This is So-and-So. I’d like to take you out.' They don’t happen. Of course not.”

While the actual star of the Golden Bachelorette has yet to be announced, a press release for the series stated that it will "highlight one radiant woman’s second chance at love in her golden years." Its announcement comes after The Golden Bachelor star Gerry Turner and his new partner, Theresa Nist, tied the knot during their televised Golden Wedding last month.

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly's free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.

Related content:

Related articles
Law & Order Camryn Manheim leaving
TV
Law & Order Camryn Manheim leaving
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Doctor Who How Jinkx Monsoon brought her musical
TV
Doctor Who How Jinkx Monsoon brought her musical
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Doctor Who,
TV
Doctor Who,
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Grey's Anatomy recap: Griffith freezes in the OR
TV
Grey's Anatomy recap: Griffith freezes in the OR
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Friday the 13thBryan Fuller exits
TV
Friday the 13thBryan Fuller exits
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Baby Reindeer stars Richard Gadd and Jessica Gunning open up about the 'complicated' stalker series
TV
Baby Reindeer stars Richard Gadd and Jessica Gunning open up about the 'complicated' stalker series
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Batman: Caped Crusader first look reveals Asian American Harley Quinn and ‘really weird’ Dark Knight
TV
Batman: Caped Crusader first look reveals Asian American Harley Quinn and ‘really weird’ Dark Knight
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Pretty Little Liars: Summer SchoolWhy Imogen's baby isn't with Ezra and Aria on
TV
Pretty Little Liars: Summer SchoolWhy Imogen's baby isn't with Ezra and Aria on
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT
Pretty Little Liars: Summer School bosses preview more horror in season 2
TV
Pretty Little Liars: Summer School bosses preview more horror in season 2
Published on April 20, 2026 EDT