NKOTB star Joey McIntyre sings satirical song about being straight in Alaska's drag musical: 'I'm clearly not gay'
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT

Joey McIntyre's character in Drag: The Musical was simply born this way — and by that, he definitely means not gay.

As the New Kids on the Block performer prepares to hit the New York City stage when Drag: The Musical heads Off-Broadway later this year, Entertainment Weekly has an exclusive preview of the singer's standout number from the project, which stars and was written by RuPaul's Drag Race icon Alaska.

The boy band heartthrob stars in the production as Tom Hutchinson, a straight-laced accountant who helps his drag queen brother save his beloved drag club from financial despair. "Straight Man," which you can exclusively hear below, joins the show as a new track for its New York edition, and soundtracks a moment in the story where Tom romances Dixie Coxworth, a drag artist who was assigned female at birth.

Courtesy Shore Fire Media; Bella Marie Adams

"I always know the directions, so I never ask. I'm just a straight man," McIntyre sings in the tune, which was inspired by pop-rock singles by Weezer, Green Day, and Good Charlotte. "I might not be so fantabulous. I'm clearly not gay. I was just born this way."

Drag: The Musical also features fellow drag entertainers like Jujubee (Drag Race season 2, All Stars 1, All Stars 5) and Jan (season 12, All Stars 6), as well as pop singer Lagoona Bloo and star J. Elaine Marcos. The show's plot also incorporates the tale of a bitter split between former colleagues, with tension between two estranged queens ultimately reaching a boiling point when they both open competing clubs.

In a statement, Drag: The Musical co-writer and producer Tomas Costanza jokes that "Straight Man" is an "anthem for every dude who cracks open a cold one, swings a club, and cranks up the rock at the family barbecue," as well as "a celebration of that unapologetic, raw, heterosexual, frisbee-throwing spirit."

Adds songwriter and production writer Ashley Gordon: "This one goes out to the devoted cis hetero men who have been dragged to our musical by their own personal queens. We salute you."

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly's free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.

In addition to starring in the show, Alaska wrote Drag: The Musical alongside Costanza and Gordon.

"Straight Man" accompanies Drag: The Musical for its Off Broadway debut, with performances beginning Sept. 30 at New World Stages ahead of the show's official opening on Oct. 21. Alaska is slated to perform in the New York City production through Jan. 11, while McIntyre departs earlier on Nov. 24.

Listen to McIntyre sing "Straight Man" above.

Related articles
Crazy Rich Asians being turned into Broadway musical with director Jon M. Chu
Theater
Crazy Rich Asians being turned into Broadway musical with director Jon M. Chu
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
The Wiz review: Run, don't ease, on down the road to this spectacular revival of the classic musical
Theater
The Wiz review: Run, don't ease, on down the road to this spectacular revival of the classic musical
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
Lempicka review: The artist’s life is painted with broad and messy brush strokes in new musical
Theater
Lempicka review: The artist’s life is painted with broad and messy brush strokes in new musical
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
Merrily We Roll AlongDaniel Radcliffe comes unglued singing 'Franklin Shepard Inc.' in
Theater
Merrily We Roll AlongDaniel Radcliffe comes unglued singing 'Franklin Shepard Inc.' in
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
The Outsiders review: S.E. Hinton's beloved novel transforms into glittering Broadway musical
Theater
The Outsiders review: S.E. Hinton's beloved novel transforms into glittering Broadway musical
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
Romeo & Juliet producers condemn 'deplorable' racist backlash aimed at Tom Holland’s costar: 'This must stop'
Theater
Romeo & Juliet producers condemn 'deplorable' racist backlash aimed at Tom Holland’s costar: 'This must stop'
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
Funny Girl takes its parade and an astounding new Fanny Brice on tour
Theater
Funny Girl takes its parade and an astounding new Fanny Brice on tour
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
The Who's Tommy review: Pete Townshend's rock opera is a Broadway sensation
Theater
The Who's Tommy review: Pete Townshend's rock opera is a Broadway sensation
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT
Hell's KitchenAlicia Keys and
Theater
Hell's KitchenAlicia Keys and
Published on December 14, 2025 EDT